Italy's Garante fines Meta €805M over Facebook gallery access
Italy's Garante fined Meta €805M over Facebook for Android's default-on gallery suggestions, citing Article 122 ePrivacy. Meta has 60 days to fix consent and plans to appeal.
Italy's data-protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million on 14 November 2026 over a Facebook for Android feature that suggests photos and videos from a user's phone gallery to post. The authority found the feature — live since 2023 and enabled by default — accessed Italian users' gallery content without free and informed consent. The fine is about 0.47% of Meta's global turnover. This post cites the Garante's order as primary, with reporting at The Hacker News and SecurityWeek.
What the regulator found
The gallery-suggestions function ("Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook") was bundled into a single, app-wide permission introduced by a vague "enable other features" notice. The Garante held that this kind of blanket authorization could give the app ongoing access to a user's entire photo archive, and that the feature being on by default compounded the problem. About 20 million Android users in Italy were in scope.
The legal basis is Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive — not the GDPR's data-transfer rules. The distinction matters: the Garante held that reading data stored on a device requires consent "whether or not data is transmitted or harm occurs." It also rejected Meta's argument that Ireland's DPC should handle the case under the one-stop-shop, noting ePrivacy has no such mechanism — a jurisdictional point other EU authorities will read closely.
The obligations
The order sets three deadlines Meta must meet:
- Within 30 days — report the initiatives it has launched to comply.
- Within 60 days — request consent through a separate, specific request and keep the feature off by default, including for users who already granted the bundled permission. Miss this, and the feature cannot be activated for anyone without valid consent.
- Within 90 days — report the measures actually adopted.
Meta's response
Meta plans to appeal and called the fine "disproportionate," per a spokesperson quoted by Reuters. The company says the feature runs only after a user grants permission on the device and can be turned off in settings. The Garante treated Meta's post-complaint changes as mitigating but "late and limited," and weighed as aggravating the number of people affected, the duration, a 2019 decision against the company, and limited cooperation during the investigation. The case did not examine AI training — which Meta denies doing with this content — and the authority reserved the right to assess separately a 2026 cloud-processing feature for gallery content.
Context
This extends the European line of enforcement aimed at how default-on data access is engineered, not just where data ends up. It lands weeks after Norway's Datatilsynet fined Microsoft's Xandr 92M NOK over real-time-bidding data — the same pattern of a regulator pricing a design choice, not a breach. For AppSec and mobile teams, the operative lesson is narrow: a device permission is not consent for a specific purpose, and "the user can turn it off" is not a defense when the feature ships on by default.